Yep, it's another Almighty movie, this time starring Steve Carell! Carell played Evan Baxter, the jerk who stole Bruce's job, in Bruce Almighty.
Plot from IMDB: Newly elected to Congress, Evan (Steve Carell) leaves Buffalo behind and shepherds his family to suburban northern Virginia. Once there, his life gets turned upside-down when God (Morgan Freeman) appears and mysteriously commands him to build an ark. But his befuddled family just can't decide whether Evan is having an extraordinary mid-life crisis or is truly onto something of Biblical proportions.
IMDB & USA Today & Wikipedia