More pics after cut
Here is Keith's sketch vs Giambattista Valli Spring 2006
Another Keith sketch vs Lacoste Spring 2006 collection
Yet another sketch vs Marni Spring 2006
Edited to Add:
I cant believe that people are still hitting this post but since they are, I will add Keith's response to these pictures which he posted on various blogs. I am not going to comment on it because I have every confidence that you can make your own mind up. :-)
"love your site and i read it often. so when i read the latest comments about me i thought it might be time to write in. for the record, i submitted 5 portfolios for the judges review. the one you seem to be focusing on was a research assignment i did for a client in which i reviewed key fashion trends. i'm very proud of all the work that i do. the panel of judges that reviewed my work had many years of experience behind them. i found them neither ignorant, uninformed or in any way confused about their own profession."