munchma quchi (revertigo) wrote in ohnotheydidnt,
munchma quchi
revertigo
ohnotheydidnt

Scientists, Skinthusiasts and a Dermatologist Review FENTY SKIN

FentySkin.jpg
If you are a skincare junkie like me, you might have seen your favorite influencers and glorified undisclosed Youth to the People sales rep skincare "specialists" roll out their videos demonstrating and recommending Rihanna's FENTY BEAUTY ahead of its official July 31 launch. Most reviews are very enthusiastic, calling the $75 line (if you purchase the cleanser, toner and SPF moisturizer in a bundle) a great introduction into skincare. Many consumers, however, have pointed out the clear bias in the reviews because 1) they were sent PR packages and 2) the same influencers have criticized celebrity competitor lines (notably Kylie Skin) for the same or less (sketchy formulations, quick cash grab).

Rihanna stanning aside, here are reviews from smaller Youtubers who weren't sent PR and are inclined to focus on formulations:


April Basi, a cosmetic chemist

Summary
  • Cleanser: not a fan of coconut surfactants because they can be problematic.
  • On fragrance: appreciates the brand's transparency on fragrance being 1% of the formulation but because "fragrance" is an umbrella term and with there being so many functioning groups that make up fragrance, it could still be irritating
  • In general: a lot of antioxidants but wishes there were more actives; moisturizer/sunscreen is her favorite product from the line

    Valento/ValentoSkincare, Biological Scientist

    Summary
  • Does a head-to-head comparison of FENTY SKIN vs KYLIE SKIN
  • Toners: wonders why Fenty skin contains witch hazel, which could be drying. wishes Fenty skin disclosed % of niacinamide. Doesn't like toners from either brand
  • Cleansers: prefers FENTY
  • SPF: Most important step so appreciates that Rihanna launched with an SPF in her starter kit, but KYLIE Skin's SPF is better because it's fragrance-free and is likely to perform the same w/o irritation risk
  • Overall, doesn't think FENTY skin is suitable for acne-prone or sensitive skin types

    Sarah Cheung, a reliable influencer

    Summary
  • Gushes over the gender-neutral and environmentally-conscious marketing
  • Likes the simplicity of the line
  • Biggest negative from the line is the fragrance. Recognizes that this complaint can be obnoxious in the skincare community but many people aren't educated on the risks so they can't make informed decisions. It's important because the market overwhelmingly uses fragrances and people with fragrance sensitivity/sensitive skin in general cannot opt out. The merits of using fragrance does not outweigh potential risks.
  • Fat Water Toner is her least favorite product because of the witch hazel.
  • Is opened to trying the SPF moisturizer.

    Dr. Dray, an actual specialist
    Summary
  • Criticizes the "insider" marketing
  • Touted exotic ingredients like the Barbados cherries, fig and raisin tree aren't revolutionary, are actually very common in skincare and/or unlikely to do much
  • Niacinamide is a good, evidence-based ingredient but it's a dime-a-dozen in many other affordable skincare lines
  • Does not think the cleanser will be a good "all in one" cleanser like it claims
  • Echos aforementioned concerns regarding fragrance in skincare and witch hazel
  • The SPF Moisturizer is not worth the $35 pricetag because it uses outdated UV filters to be in compliance with US FDA regulations. There are better alternatives on the market at better value w/o fragrance.
  • More on SPF: "Coral reef safe" is gimmicky marketing because lab studies are inadequate and haven't establish a direct link yet. The focus should be more on climate change.
  • More criticism on marketing: being "environmentally conscious" means not coming out with yet another skincare line that would just create more waste while not offering anything new to the market


    Sources: April Basi, VALENTOSKINCARE, Sarah Cheung, Dr. Dray
  • Tags: beauty / makeup, rihanna
    Subscribe
    • Post a new comment

      Error

      Comments allowed for members only

      Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

      default userpic

      Your reply will be screened

      Your IP address will be recorded 

    • 479 comments
    Previous
    ← Ctrl ← Alt
    Next
    Ctrl → Alt →
    Previous
    ← Ctrl ← Alt
    Next
    Ctrl → Alt →