In a historic photo that nearly broke the Internet, 2014 Oscar host Ellen Degeneres managed to capture some of the world’s most sought-after movie stars in a single frame. One thing it was missing, though? Her perfect match. Earlier this week, the “Are You the One?” cast all got together to film a reunion special, and when they had a spare second off stage, Ryan whipped out his camera in an effort to one-up the talk-show host. “It’s not quite Ellen-status…but still quite a selfie!” he wrote with the pic above.