ONTD

1:36 pm - 02/06/2013

It’s Like That Shocking Head Shaving Apology Never Happened



Last week, Japanese singer Minami Minegishi shaved her head after a tabloid photographed her leaving a boy band member's house. In the strict world of Japanese idols, dating boys is a no-no. Cover-ups, however, are totally fine.

After Minegishi's group AKB48 uploaded her shaved head video apology on its official YouTube channel, the clip soon went viral. It even became international news, with people around the world wondering what the hell was going on with this young woman, her group, and its rules.

Cynics said the whole thing was a publicity stunt. Whatever it was, the incident blew up in the group's face. Apparently feeling the blowback, the YouTube apology was changed to private. It didn't matter if the video had already clocked six million views. The cover-up, it seems, was beginning.

Aside from the self-inflicted shaving and the humiliating apology, part of Minegishi's punishment was a demotion. In the wake of the scandal, she was moved to the lowest rank of the group and became a "trainee."

Yesterday, Minegishi appeared on stage as a trainee. She once again apologized for the trouble she caused and said she would try her best in her new role as a trainee. In the concert venue, there was, according to reports, "warm applause". Online, there wasn't.



People quickly noted that Minegishi, who had just shaved her head last week, now had a full head of shoulder-length hair. Minegishi, you see, wore a wig. "What, is this a joke?" wrote one commenter. "She's not sorry at all for what happened," wrote another, while yet another commenter noted, "Guess shaving her head was meaningless, lulz."

Cover-ups like this might seem innocuous, but this is largely how the Japanese entertainment industry works. So, for example, a celebrity is disgraced with a drug or a sex scandal, and said celebrity will, depending on how connected they are, will usually vanish from the entertainment world. That individual becomes taboo in the mainstream press, while the tabloids will continue to mine for lurid stories.

That means that the old clips of the disgraced celebrity will not be shown on television. If that disgraced celebrity does appear in old clips that need to be shown on TV for one reason or another, the former big shot will either be edited or blurred out.

Occasionally, old clips like these will be shown on TV, complete with mosaics, and it's an odd feeling to see faded stars shoveled over with digital dirt or buried completely. As if they never existed.



And it's not only disgraced celebs that get elbowed out. People who leave the entertainment industry and re-enter the real world are also often cut out from old clips and photos, too—often are their own request.

As alarming as this can seem (and, yes, it does seem somewhat alarming), this attitude does transcend the Japanese entertainment industry and can be found throughout society. It's this attitude that raises the ire of Japan's neighbors in Asia, but also the attitude that enables much of the country to pick itself up after horrible events and push forward—refusing to dwell on the past or assign blame, but to move on. Just like this young singer is trying to do.

The internet, whether it's in Japan or elsewhere, never forgets.

SOURCE

I hope she gets better and is able to move on from the scandal...oh and her critics need to have their heads shaved, ignorant fools...
Page 1 of 3
<<[1] [2] [3] >>
crucified 6th-Feb-2013 06:59 pm (UTC)
This whole thing is so fucked up.
wonderwomanhero 6th-Feb-2013 07:09 pm (UTC)
mte
misspoes 6th-Feb-2013 06:59 pm (UTC)
A rank? As trainee? In like, a girl singing group?
Confused.
gaybash 6th-Feb-2013 07:03 pm (UTC)
Apparently there's like 90 members of this group and only 10 or so perform at most of the concerts? IDK. I guess that's the point of the ranking system.
stephantasm 6th-Feb-2013 07:03 pm (UTC)
they have a ton of members and do shows at the same time in different subgroups. when someone in one group gets sick or something, a trainee can fill in for them. they also serve as backup dancers iirc...

why do i know this shit
plugmebaby 7th-Feb-2013 01:16 pm (UTC)
jw

my bff told me about this video on youtube, of a eurasian girl (half korean half white) talking about how she wanted to join the korean music industry but was put off because she was told to get all kinds of plastic surgery. im wondering if you know what vid it is? she says the youtube girl is a friend of kevjumba or smth
kurtvonnegut 6th-Feb-2013 07:09 pm (UTC)


yeeeeeeeah i don't really get it but it's a thing
konichiwacobra 6th-Feb-2013 07:18 pm (UTC)
to explain AKB48 would take a thousand years. Let's start by saying they were originally a theatre group who performed every night (still are) so they need to rotate girls out frequently. They are divided into teams ... for example A team K team B team consisting of various girls at the beginning 16 on each team. Trainees are another team of girls who aren't yet at the level to be in an official team. They all sing and promote the same songs. There is a voting ballot in certain singles where you can vote for your favorite member to help them move up in rank and therefore move up to get more notice.


there are also other similar groups in different cities like SKE48 or JKT48.
myharu 6th-Feb-2013 07:23 pm (UTC)
AKB is split into 3 official teams: Team A, Team K, Team B, and then there's one team for "research students"

whenever they have auditions for AKB the ones that make it become part of the research team and they have a chance to get promoted to an official team when someone from one of those teams graduate.

Minegishi was demoted to the research team (fun fact: she was around since the creation of AKB so she never had to be in the research team until now)
squirrels_oh_no 6th-Feb-2013 07:00 pm (UTC)
"What, is this a joke?" wrote one commenter. "She's not sorry at all for what happened," wrote another, while yet another commenter noted, "Guess shaving her head was meaningless, lulz."

Or maybe if she had any chances of ever keeping her dream as a pop star alive, she had to put on a wig and a smile and go back out there and do her hardest to recover her public image. She can't just go out there with a shaved head when personal appearance is 9/10ths of your job.
starchain 6th-Feb-2013 07:11 pm (UTC)
Or maybe she really isn't sorry because she did nothing wrong and they actually forced her to shave her head
squirrels_oh_no 6th-Feb-2013 07:12 pm (UTC)
That too.
saintvlas22 7th-Feb-2013 02:31 am (UTC)
Did they actually force her to do that? The last post on this made it seem like she went all Britney. Granted, it seems that they indirectly made her do it, what with the stress and blame the so-called fans and her shitty company did to her.
heart_of_butter 6th-Feb-2013 07:29 pm (UTC)
Sad that these "fans" think she should be sorry. She's a real human being, assholes. She doesn't exist solely for your entertainment/pleasure.
go3x 7th-Feb-2013 03:54 am (UTC)
These shitty, fucked-up fans make my blood boil.
winegums 7th-Feb-2013 04:43 pm (UTC)
^ mte

wtf has she done that she should even be sorry at all?
itscomicrelief 6th-Feb-2013 07:03 pm (UTC)
Aside from the self-inflicted shaving and the humiliating apology, part of Minegishi's punishment was a demotion. In the wake of the scandal, she was moved to the lowest rank of the group and became a "trainee."


Lol what. I didn't know there was rankings like that
wonderwomanhero 6th-Feb-2013 07:08 pm (UTC)
Yeah, 'trainee' is similar to a backup dancer
miindy 6th-Feb-2013 07:12 pm (UTC)
idk how it works in Jpop, but I assume it's similar to Kpop: trainees are aspiring performers who haven't yet officially made their debut as solo artists or group members. some trainees will be... well, training, under their company for years before they finally get to debut. the woman this article is about debuted in 2005, so demoting her to trainee level is sort of like erasing the past seven years of her career. it's ridiculous.
taylorniw 6th-Feb-2013 07:51 pm (UTC)
You've got it mostly down, except AKB48 trainees actually fill in for members who can't be in the theater that day. They even have their own performances and songs occasionally. iirc they've had a few of their own MVs too.

Some of the trainees are legit more popular than full time members who have been around for years.
_pinkpornstar_ 6th-Feb-2013 07:04 pm (UTC)
This whole thing baffles me. Could you imagine if American society were that strict? We would have no celebrities left.
wonderwomanhero 6th-Feb-2013 07:08 pm (UTC)
Gaga would be homeless
stephantasm 6th-Feb-2013 07:10 pm (UTC)
we would have celebrities, our culture would just be different...
ellecain 6th-Feb-2013 08:09 pm (UTC)
this
swimmingotter 6th-Feb-2013 07:21 pm (UTC)
We would have no Taylor Swift.
heart_of_butter 6th-Feb-2013 07:34 pm (UTC)
I remember one member of Da Pump was essentially erased (as the article puts it) after getting a DUI. Same thing for one of the members of Morning Musume for smoking and dating. I can't imagine how they would react to the typical American celebrity (even though Paris Hilton was popular over there for a little while)
mjspice 7th-Feb-2013 02:32 am (UTC)
No Nicki Minaj.
m_h_p 6th-Feb-2013 07:04 pm (UTC)
I can't understand this ridiculous level of shaming.

Especially when nothing too bad seems to have happened to the guy in this situation?
bulastar 6th-Feb-2013 07:11 pm (UTC)
He was from a boy band with a different agency. They probably have different rules, or just the usualy male-female double standards.

Though Johnny's Entertainment (which is all boy bands) are held up to ridiculously high standards too, but I don't know of any specific sex scandals involving the male idols. Anyone here with knowledge in this area?
benihime99 6th-Feb-2013 07:17 pm (UTC)
Several johnny's had sex scandal but were never shamed like that (Aiba, Nino, Ryo, Jin, MatsuJun...). Actually a few are married or have girlfriends

Now drug and/or alcohol (when minors) is a no go
delicious_pocky 6th-Feb-2013 08:44 pm (UTC)
well, in johnny's entertainment, johnny raped plenty of young boys so there's that little scandal.... which obviously was covered-up by japanese media.
konichiwacobra 6th-Feb-2013 07:20 pm (UTC)
he's from GENERATIONS from EXILE TRIBE (different group/agency) and they're not idols. They basically said they didn't care what he did in private.

her company was the one with the stupid ass no dating clause.
xtoki_dokix 6th-Feb-2013 08:38 pm (UTC)
He didn't get in trouble because his agency didn't care.

Male pop stars usually arent allowed to date either. If they marry, they have to ask when they can. They can't just do what they want all willynilly either. I think I've even heard of a male idol who had a fan commit suicide when he announced he was dating. This is why they became strict.

But in this case, his agency respects his privacy. Its HER agency that doesnt. I honestly think she should just leave them. But doing that would be even more career suicide than staying.

The guy did apologize in front of all his fans before his concert yesterday though. He does seem very sorry about what happened and what she's going through.
aquaricom 6th-Feb-2013 07:07 pm (UTC)
wait! How can they say this is a coverup and that nothing ever happened, but they still make her go through with the "demotion"?? ridic...

and here I was hoping she would come back empowered and fierce after knowing the world was speaking out for her rights, but naaaaaaaah....I guess the allure of being just a another loli in the stables with limited shelf life was just way to tempting to turn down
stellar_ball 6th-Feb-2013 07:15 pm (UTC)
I don't know much about this pop/celeb world in Japan, but from these last few articles I would assume she probably will never hear about the support she's receiving.
aquaricom 6th-Feb-2013 07:22 pm (UTC)
You have a point, I highly doubt any of the worldwide buzz was translated back into japanese, but I do remember a japanese article saying the world knew and they were embarrassed at how their country looked as a whole.

Even most japanese think the rules are extreme and idol FANS are the real cancer. In my opinion the fact that the video was posted on the official channel was really disturbing, I think these girls are definitely on the receiving end on some abuse from their handlers.

benihime99 6th-Feb-2013 07:29 pm (UTC)
At least she did get support from co-member and even ex-member
chidarkcy 6th-Feb-2013 07:09 pm (UTC)
She shaved because she spent a night with her bf and got caught? wow...

I don´t know much about japanese culture but I was surprised when a japanese friend told me if they ever got a tattoo they cannot share public places like a pool because is considered an offense and bad influence for children.
yurasama_love 6th-Feb-2013 07:14 pm (UTC)
In Japan, yakuza members are people who get tattoos, so regular folk do not approve.
benihime99 6th-Feb-2013 07:17 pm (UTC)
It's also linked to the yakuza culture
loveumbrella 6th-Feb-2013 07:21 pm (UTC)
Because tattoos are still very much linked to yakuza over there.

edit oop they already said it, well I think you got the point :D

Edited at 2013-02-06 07:22 pm (UTC)
mana_runigha 7th-Feb-2013 12:06 am (UTC)
That last bit is true. I had a friend who was not allowed at a public bath due to a tattoo of a lion she had.

They are still linked to the Yakuza culture, but firemen and fisherman would sport similar tattoos a long long time ago.

Edited at 2013-02-07 12:07 am (UTC)
mjspice 7th-Feb-2013 02:34 am (UTC)
Lol what everyone said but there are still many Jpop celebs that have gotten tattoos & aren't the Yakuza like Miyavi, Ayumi Hamasaki & even recently GACKT got one.
yurasama_love 6th-Feb-2013 07:12 pm (UTC)
This is crazy.
la_petite_singe 6th-Feb-2013 07:20 pm (UTC)
So, okay, sorry for the stupid question, but in this case "idols" just means "famous pop singer"? Like, she's not connected with a specific show or something? I know lots of countries have their versions of American Idol, so is she under some kind of contract...?
wonderwomanhero 6th-Feb-2013 07:24 pm (UTC)
Idol has a rather different meaning. It's like higher than simply referring to someone as a 'pop singer' or 'musician'
delicious_pocky 6th-Feb-2013 08:46 pm (UTC)
it's higher but it's also lower 'cause japanese society treats idols as disposable and with no prestige while musicians/actors are respected.
konichiwacobra 6th-Feb-2013 07:26 pm (UTC)
idol is a pop singer that is marketed to teens really. They sing music that is clean and innocent (it's hard for me to describe, but think disney/nickelodeon) and they're marketed as being nice and wholesome. It's not just a pop singer because there are plenty of pop singers who aren't idols.

It's has nothing to do with Pop Idol or American Idol or any other tv show. It's just a term.
benihime99 6th-Feb-2013 07:27 pm (UTC)
It's a bit more than a famous pop singer
Wikipedia might help (worded better than I could)

delicious_pocky 6th-Feb-2013 08:49 pm (UTC)
the purpose of an idol is basically to give the agency the biggest profit possible. so they usually act and sing and do lots of things but they do it all in a mediocre way 'cause their whole thing is being "relatable" and "girls/guys next door". their main purpose, though, is to star in as many commercials as possible 'cause that's where the money's at and that's the reason why they need a cleancut image 'cause obviously companies/advertisers don't want to be associated with stars with a bad rep.
mmmdraco 6th-Feb-2013 07:21 pm (UTC)
She is not the first girl in AKB to be demoted because of a scandal. She was one of the most popular members and she's seen other girls go because of scandal. She played this exactly right for herself. She gets to stay in the group to keep most of her fans and gain some new ones and now she'll have a little time to relax a bit before being popular and in ad campaigns and dramas again.
theantipoet 6th-Feb-2013 07:22 pm (UTC)
Japan is weird.

I can't bring myself to trust any culture that won't even show a penis in porn.
bralesss 6th-Feb-2013 07:24 pm (UTC)
1 time i watched japanese porn with my ex...we were not expecting the pixels. needless to say we X'd out of the window lol
wonderwomanhero 6th-Feb-2013 07:25 pm (UTC)
So? They can't show it they can't show it, you move on with life and deal with the little black bar over the foreskin.
theantipoet 6th-Feb-2013 07:26 pm (UTC)
it's just a cultural weirdness that makes me judge the country.

octopus tentacles raping a girl? great! penis? verboten.
saintsmarching 6th-Feb-2013 08:23 pm (UTC)
It's forbidden to show pubic hair actually, not the parts themselves iirc.
konichiwacobra 6th-Feb-2013 07:23 pm (UTC)
and everything about this continues to be ridiculous.
bralesss 6th-Feb-2013 07:23 pm (UTC)
poor girl, those people are fucking idiots
greenfairy_87 6th-Feb-2013 07:24 pm (UTC)
Punishing women for having sex=what's always fueled the misogyny train on the track to DumbFuckVille.
Page 1 of 3
<<[1] [2] [3] >>
This page was loaded May 23rd 2013, 2:56 am GMT.