ONTD

3:38 pm - 12/07/2012

Is Lindsay Lohan Benefiting From White Privilege?



It feels like every time I turn on the TV these days, there goes another story about Lindsay Lohan getting arrested. Clearly, the young lady needs help, but rarely does she receive more than a slap on the wrist for whatever she’s accused of. Before people start calling me a Lohan-hater, let me say that I have absolutely nothing against her. Truth be told, I feel for her. What I am troubled by is the fact that she and other White celebrities seem to get special treatment in the criminal justice system and in so many other arenas.

There are some people that are quick to accuse us of using the race card, but how can we be at fault when we see racial disparities everywhere we turn? People are well aware of economic, educational, and housing inequalities, but we also see the constant unbalanced treatment of our favorite actors, artists, and athletes.

If a rapper (pick any), so much as jaywalks, he/she gets the book thrown at them — this goes for any and every kind of celebrity of color. How many times do we see them arrested, charged, or serving time for many of the things that we’ve already watched Lohan and others get a free pass on? And they have the nerve to say WE are the ones holding on to race. But every corner we turn, there’s a privilege being thrown in our face.

Let’s not pretend that this is all about Lohan, though.

How many times have we witnessed other White celebs get away with a slap on the wrist? Can anyone say, “Paris Hilton”?! The problem isn’t only about this unfair treatment, however, but rather what sort of example these women and others like them are setting for young White girls.

We often discuss Rihanna‘s actions and her impact on impressionable young girls. But why do we never speak about Lohan’s behavior and her responsibility to serve as a positive role model? Despite everything she has done, it seems as though folks in Hollywood glamorize her. “Liz and Dick” is the latest example of Lohan’s continued celebrity, which could be found on buses and billboards everywhere. Ironically, Lohan plays Elizabeth Taylor who had severe addiction issues. Is this supposed to be some form of reverse therapy?

At the end of the day, we’re sending the wrong message to young people everywhere when a person can be repeatedly arrested or accused of serious offenses, yet somehow not be held accountable. When the youth of America and the world see this over and over again, they think that they, too, can behave like this when they grow up. And that is just simply not true.

Some will blame a person’s parents, environment, or societal influences. But whatever the reason, at the end of the day, we are ultimately responsible for our actions, and those in the limelight have the added duty of serving as examples to others. While Lohan’s most-recent arrest may not be Lohan’s fault, in each instance, the common denominator is always HER.

If it turns out that she’s guilty, will we see the same kind of punishment if it were Rihanna who committed the same crime?

I don’t know. Is it White privilege, money, or am I just buggin’?

Source
Page 4 of 5
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] >>
nene718 8th-Dec-2012 01:34 am (UTC)
answer: yes

end of post
flumes 8th-Dec-2012 01:41 am (UTC)
of course she is. this is such a dumb question.
vonlisbon 8th-Dec-2012 01:43 am (UTC)
I totally agree that race factors in to even celebrity prosecutions, but wtf is this "article"? It's just a bunch of random-ass unsupported generalizations. Like, this shit is so common, it's just plain lazy to be like "oh rappers r treated differently google it yourself"
run_atreyu 8th-Dec-2012 01:46 am (UTC)
Well obviously she's benefitting from white privilege; she's white. Ditto other types of privilege going in her favour: wealth/beauty. I think, though, that the very fact that Lindsay (and Rihanna) are so high profile and we even dissect and critique them in the media the way we do is entirely down to the fact that they're female. The absence of male privilege is what has made them the poster children they are. So there's a discussion to be had here and I wouldn't normally derail from discussing race, but it does feel in this case that if you have this conversation without even acknowledging the intersectionality of gender then you're missing a really critical piece of the puzzle.

Setting that aside, I'm not sure whether Lindsay/Rihanna is the best comparison. But there are so few young black celebrities that I can't think of a young woman who's in a similar situation where she's broken the law several times for low level offenses and spent barely any time in jail. Nicole Richie is a young woman of colour who was previously in the same situation and she didn't spend much time in prison, either. It's a tough one because I'm interested in this conversation but I don't think the comparison of a young black woman who has committed no crimes but has been the survivor of domestic abuse can be easily equated to a young white woman with some substance problems who's committed a few minor crimes. Clearly Rihanna is held up as a role model and Lindsay isn't, so the writer has something there. And that's very likely largely related to race and particularly because there aren't many black role models, so the ones out there have a lot more weight on their shoulders. Whereas Lindsay has a lot of young, white contemporaries who can be viewed as role models.
rogue 8th-Dec-2012 02:46 am (UTC)
you can't argue nicole ritchie's case. she may identify as a person of color, but she is white passing, and therefore benefits from white privilege.
run_atreyu 8th-Dec-2012 02:51 am (UTC)
Yeah. I find that weird tbh, but you're right that most people view her as white. She was the only person I could think of, though.
hollis1975 8th-Dec-2012 01:52 am (UTC)
uh yeah. RICH WHITE PRIVILEGE
andieray 8th-Dec-2012 01:56 am (UTC)
Obviously.
josh_the_k 8th-Dec-2012 01:58 am (UTC)
oceanhue 8th-Dec-2012 02:02 am (UTC)
The sky is blue, everyone here is in student loan debt and I'm also hungry, etc.
rogue 8th-Dec-2012 02:20 am (UTC)
without even reading this article

a resounding YES

if she wasn't white people wouldn't keep trying to look at her as a fascinating trainwreck to still be sympathized with (at times), and constantly rooted for and supported for a comeback.

this bitch would have been a nobody years ago if she wasn't white, and white people should gtfo with it

bye.
ohyoudo 8th-Dec-2012 02:24 am (UTC)
trigger warning for that picture pls
mercystars 8th-Dec-2012 02:40 am (UTC)
if you have to ask...............
rogue 8th-Dec-2012 02:45 am (UTC)
some white british guy just tried to argue he didn't benefit from white privilege because he's disabled and in britain he can't get a job b/c the system favors minorities


LIKE WHY

WHY DO PEOPLE SAY DUMB SHIT LIKE THAT TO ME
daladoir 8th-Dec-2012 02:52 am (UTC)
Ugh oh my god the same thing happened to me. Except the guy was trying to tell me a tale about how he grew up on a poor farm or some shit.
camillesaens 8th-Dec-2012 03:44 am (UTC)
Ikr. Call me when you get stopped at the airport three times, asshole.
treebraids 8th-Dec-2012 10:46 am (UTC)
LMAO! I wish the system favored me.
evett 8th-Dec-2012 04:45 am (UTC)
White Privilege + Rich Privilege (ie affording good lawyers)
prophecypro 8th-Dec-2012 05:14 am (UTC)
Yeah. At the same time I;m sure some people are slightly targeting her but she needs to be away from those situations where that may happen
kp199 8th-Dec-2012 05:38 am (UTC)
No fucking doubt. If she were black, she'd have been in the slammer AGES ago.
Page 4 of 5
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] >>
This page was loaded May 23rd 2013, 8:29 am GMT.