ONTD

4:09 pm - 11/14/2012

MTV’s ‘Catfish’ TV Show Succeeds Where The Film Failed

dev

Sometimes a TV show really can be better than the film from whence it came. 
In 2010, Nev Shulman debuted his documentary, Catfish, which followed his journey to meet the girl he fell in love with on Facebook. Despite the marketing campaign for the film, which positioned it as some horror flick with a dangerous or paranormal twist, Shulman’s journey (SPOILER ALERT!) ended in a farmhouse with a middle-aged mother and wife who’d been creating false Facebook personas to stave off her own loneliness and boredom. It was an unexpected twist, for sure, but where audiences were expecting pure, radical shock and awe, we found our surprise coupled with something truly, deeply sad: a person whose life was so unlike the life they wanted that they felt the need to create another. When translated into a television show with a premise based up front on that emotional concept, the product is something that feels as if it has the momentum to move the discovery forward, instead of wallowing in the shock of the 180-degree turnaround. 

The first episode of Catfish: The TV Show, focuses on Sunny, a young woman who’s in an online relationship with a male model in L.A. … who also works at Chelsea Lately and writes for the show … and also writes cue cards? What an overachiever! In truth, as most viewers probably guessed from the premise of the show, this wonderful, magical Skype-allergic RJ guy is actually an 18 year-old girl named Chelsea who started the account as a means of revenge against someone who bullied her on Facebook. The lie started to consume her because she felt like an outcast in real life, and her online model persona afforded her the means to make easy connections with other girls online as she explored her bisexuality. And that’s where the show truly manages to surpass its cinematic source material. 

Read more...Collapse )

Source 

Anyone ever been in an online relationship and found out that everything the other person told them was a lie?



(Not me. An interesting lesbian online dating horror story.) 


Page 6 of 9
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] >>
dragoncrab88 14th-Nov-2012 11:28 pm (UTC)
I am far too paranoid to do online dating anymore

My worst experience was when I had met someone I actually liked but they did not want to talk to me on the phone or meet in real life. He just wanted to text. I thought that was far too fishy.

Not to mention I can read creepy on someone right away when I meet them in person. Online it's sometimes a lot harder just judging from a profile pic that may not even be accurate anymore

Edited at 2012-11-14 11:38 pm (UTC)
palebluedot09 14th-Nov-2012 11:29 pm (UTC)
sort of had something like this happen but offline..

had a friend in hs.. she was sort of friends with a lot of guys caz she was in to sports. so anyways.. so one day she started telling me she was dating a certain guy on the football team. how he lived by her and such an such. i talked to the both of them online on aim. that lasted prob like a week or two. then i was talking to someone in my seminar about them and they ended up telling me they weren't dating. i confronted the friend about it and she got all mad. a day or two later she apologized.

flashfoward to later in the year.. i had a certain teacher for a class of mine and he was the varsity football coach. i enjoyed his class. first time i ever got an A in math. well anyways.. so the year after i had this certain teacher, this same "friend" said she had him. i would walk with her to class and then leave just before the bell rang. one day i was talking to another friend of mine and he said he had that same teacher the same period. the only problem was that he was in calc and this "friend" was not smart enough to be in calc. so i ended up walking with her to class and dropping her off like normal. i went around the corner and waited and here she came strolling out and around the corner. i mean WTF who would lie about something so stupid like that? i wonder how many tardies she must have had. and all while this was going on before i found out she said that she used to see this teacher outside of school bc a coworker of hers was dating them and she used to hang out with them. (yeah come on now.. like i believe that) it also makes things she did really creepy like bringing gifts for said teacher caz he was the football coach. and idk.. now i look back and think man was i gullible back in hs. plus other friends have since told me that she seemed sort of possessive over me and i wonder if like she was jealous of me. but yeah.. that was my brief time with an uncontrollable liar. i'm really embarrassed bout it nowadays that i feel for all that back when i was younger.
squishinator 14th-Nov-2012 11:54 pm (UTC)
lmao WTF why would she care if you thought she had some teacher??? she def has issues.

lies are too much work to keep up with i'd rather not.
ohkimosabe 15th-Nov-2012 06:14 am (UTC)
sounds like a pathological liar.
n0goodnik 16th-Nov-2012 04:31 am (UTC)
Replying super later but I had a friend in high school who was also a pathological liar about the most banal shit like this. She lied for years about being on some swimming team... and she made up some "soccer camp" she went to (she was actually on the soccer team, at least). And she said she had asthma and carried an inhaler but she was lying about that as well! There was more, but I can't remember.

Somehow it all came out and a bunch of us confronted her over it during lunch. It was the drama of the year. But after like a week, everyone else went back to being her friend. Then of course they'd find out she'd made up some new lie and be betrayed all over again! I didn't really understand why they kept trusting her. Once I knew she was such a liar, I took EVERYTHING she said with a huge grain of salt.
powerbottom 14th-Nov-2012 11:31 pm (UTC)
If you're stupid enough to fall for people who won't go on cam with you within a couple of weeks, that's your fault.

It's 2012, everyone has a cam/camera. If you don't, they're like 10 bucks at Best Buy.
bbbitchface 14th-Nov-2012 11:44 pm (UTC)
seriously, the girl in the first episode clearly didn't WANT to believe on the possibility it could all be a lie. they were telling her how they did some research and some things sounded sketchy and she would make excuses for everything.
spencoid 14th-Nov-2012 11:32 pm (UTC)
E-dated someone for a year on myspace, talked on the phone everyday- and made multiple plans to visit each other. I even drove 5 hours one time to visit him at his apartment but when I got there the place was empty. We "broke up" out of my frustration over never being able to meet and a 6 months later found out he had stolen all his pictures, and his friends were all fake too.
You believe a lot when you're lonely and young (and gay in a small town)
I confronted his AIM a couple years later about it and he showed me new pictures that werent bad at all but who knows if those were real either.
loaded___gun 15th-Nov-2012 01:46 am (UTC)
i watched the show and looking from the outside, it was super easy to call shenanigans, however, i believe this girl didn't want to hear the truth even though she probably knew it all along.
francesbcobain 14th-Nov-2012 11:41 pm (UTC)
I've never told anyone this, but I spoke to a guy online when I was 11 and he lied about his age. Anyway I spoke to him again as a 15 year old and found out he was 24. I can't do math, but he was definitely a pedo and like ugh he was probably grooming me. It makes me sick to even think about it. I feel so stupid. :( And I'm so scared he'll find me online or irl because I was stupid enough to tell him the town I lived in. I hate myself sfm.

Edited at 2012-11-14 11:42 pm (UTC)
bbbitchface 14th-Nov-2012 11:42 pm (UTC)
I find this Nev guy so hot
__redrightankle 14th-Nov-2012 11:50 pm (UTC)
same!!
loaded___gun 15th-Nov-2012 01:46 am (UTC)
me too
sugary_placenta 16th-Nov-2012 07:15 am (UTC)
he is very hot and has a great smile.
warriorholmes 14th-Nov-2012 11:46 pm (UTC)
I'm glad I wasn't the only one who faked an identity at a young age.

God. I was so bored. Sf embarassing LOL. -_- I'm afraid things like this will catch up to me which is why I'm more private now lol.

Ps. Nev is so hot. I wish he was gay~

Edited at 2012-11-14 11:46 pm (UTC)
spencoid 14th-Nov-2012 11:53 pm (UTC)
is that you in your icon?
warriorholmes 14th-Nov-2012 11:54 pm (UTC)
Lol no

It's a fierce drag queen named Raven
squishinator 14th-Nov-2012 11:55 pm (UTC)
haha its def why im more skeptical of people bc i know how that shit works having been on the other side. I wonder how many of the people i was faking with were faking me?
helloneworld 14th-Nov-2012 11:48 pm (UTC)
i've been online friends with this girl for over 10 years and in a few weeks we will meet.

and yes i know she is real and not fake. we've vid chat, exchanged gifts and sent pictures over our cells.
beetsbearsbsg 15th-Nov-2012 02:11 am (UTC)
good luck with the meet up!
sugary_placenta 16th-Nov-2012 07:17 am (UTC)
i've had an online friend for like 13 years and we've never met irl lol. tbh i don't want to because i like her online personality so much i'm afraid meeting irl would ruin that.

(holy shit i can't believe it's been 13 years. just re-reading that is freaking me out!)

Edited at 2012-11-16 07:17 am (UTC)
cukoo4cocopuffs 14th-Nov-2012 11:50 pm (UTC)
I know of two crazy ass stories. One where the person actually got involved in some psychotic 'love triangle' where it was the same person pretending to be two people AND a fake pregnancy to boot! And the other is one where the girl has been in love with some guy for 5+ years and she's traveled across the country to visit him 4x and he bails each time.
squishinator 14th-Nov-2012 11:58 pm (UTC)
she sounds stupid as fuck to TRAVEL to meet someone and they bail and it to have happened more than once. Once i met a guy online dating and he BEGGED me to meet..like wouldnt let it go so im like ok, w/e fine. Then that day he ~couldnt~ bc his car was in the shop. ok?

thennnn we made plans AGAIN and he said he was on his way... an hour later he's still "on his way." even mentioned buildings he was near and stuff (which were super close to me) and then more time passes and im like... the fuck? are you coming? he didnt reply for the longest so im like ok fuck off idiot. He claaaaimed he got "nervous" and went home but im pretty sure he never even left. I never spoke to him again and I wonder if he was even a real person lmao. It was annoying bc like i didnt even WANT to meet him to begin with. like wtf?
cukoo4cocopuffs 15th-Nov-2012 12:03 am (UTC)
He always had an excuse and she bought into it. I mean, she did see him on skype, so she knew he physically existed and looked the way he did.
shanny_w 15th-Nov-2012 06:31 am (UTC)
LOL Did he use google earth street view to get some shop names?
spillvegas 14th-Nov-2012 11:54 pm (UTC)
my high school ex put my cell number on 4chan and this one guy from texas called. he sounded like a typical college-aged dude but claimed he was younger than me. we ended up talking like once a week for well over a year. we had phone sex a bunch of times and it was awesome. never saw what he looked like but he had a nice voice. awkward
thishollywood 15th-Nov-2012 01:31 am (UTC)
Lol get it
sugary_placenta 16th-Nov-2012 07:19 am (UTC)
lmao this sounds like something i'd do tbh.
abyss_skyward 14th-Nov-2012 11:58 pm (UTC)
In eighth grade, this girl in my class made up a fake myspace account to fuck around with me. She pretended to be guy and pm tried to make me ~fall for him. I stopped messaging back when I looked shit up and realized this guy didn't go to the high school nearby. It wasn't until years later when that girl contacted me to confess and apologize for what she did, that I knew what was up. It wasn't too upsetting, but in retrospect, it's still humiliating when I think about how all the girls at school knew about it.
francesbcobain 15th-Nov-2012 12:08 am (UTC)
What a psycho. I'm sorry, love.
tropigalia 15th-Nov-2012 12:16 am (UTC)
LOL SOMEONE DID THAT TO ME TOO but i didn't fall for it at all. she kept trying anyway.

OVER XANGA.
williammiller 15th-Nov-2012 01:50 am (UTC)
A girl did that to me in 8th grade too! First she pretended to be a guy and when that didn't work, she just started sending me nasty messages. A guy who I was friends with IMed her to find out who it was and he found out it was this girl who I legit never talked to in my entire life. She was on the soccer team and we had no friends in common. I was so confused as to why she said all those mean things to me.
abyss_skyward 15th-Nov-2012 02:10 am (UTC)
Ah, that's terrible. I'm sorry that happened, bb. I immediately thought of this:

pretty_hostel 15th-Nov-2012 03:00 am (UTC)
In grade 7 a girl in my year pestered me every day trying to find out who I had a crush on and then when I finally told her she got together with a couple of her friends and called me at my house and pretended to be said crush and asked me out. Rough morning at school the next day, ending up with my crush shooting me down in front of his entire class. Middle school, fun times bro.
ohkimosabe 15th-Nov-2012 06:19 am (UTC)
Reminds me of this awful story :( http://abcnews.go.com/TheLaw/story?id=4861399&page=1
mountainblack 15th-Nov-2012 12:00 am (UTC)
this one girl was in this private comm with me and some of my friends and the entire time no one really liked her but we never really bothered to kick her out

she was always really sketchy cause nothing she said ever made sense and there were a lot of gaps in what she shared about her and this one time she posted a picture of herself and months (idek maybe a year later) drama happened and one of my friends photobucket searched hooters brunette girl or st and found the picture that she used and it was so amazing but creepy cause this girl had seen so much of our personal stuff and she was lying the entire time to us

the entire time she was pretending she was this girl about to enter columbia university and all this and she made a bunch of new lj identities but we always found them and we found her real tumblr recently and it turns out she was this 14 year old
lmao
mountainblack 15th-Nov-2012 12:02 am (UTC)
she pretended that she was an italian girl in nyc named amelia and it was soo weird that she lied about her ethnicity cause there was already another south asian person (me) in our comm

she was really obsessive and stalkerish about us cause she kept changing her mind on everything to copy certain members opinions and try to become them

Edited at 2012-11-15 12:03 am (UTC)
fapattack 15th-Nov-2012 12:04 am (UTC)
who was twizz '11
i was der
treradical 15th-Nov-2012 12:07 am (UTC)
greatest thing i've done with my life
fapattack 15th-Nov-2012 12:08 am (UTC)
♥ my hero ♥
francesbcobain 15th-Nov-2012 12:09 am (UTC)
Sis, you can't just say this and not say her username.
likejesussaid 15th-Nov-2012 12:31 am (UTC)
good times
tropigalia 15th-Nov-2012 12:14 am (UTC)
god i've been on a fucking million dates from the internet and no one has ever been deceitful about who they were, maybe because i am pretty practiced at detecting internet lies? the usual problem is that they're just boring or slightly more ugly IRL than they were on the internet. or it just doesn't work.
simprov 15th-Nov-2012 12:18 am (UTC)
i used to make friends in guilds on neopets. i'm still facebook friends with 3 girls i was friends with in a harry potter guild when i was 14. i know they're really who they say they are but i'm the one who told them a fake first name lol. i also used to pretend i was bulgarian on neopets when i was like 11. idek why
this summer i went to disneyland with one of my online friends. she turned out to be a huge weirdo and tried to feed pigeons sasstronaut :)
sasstronaut 15th-Nov-2012 12:20 am (UTC)
WOW
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW
WOWOWOWOOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW
AT LEAST I DIDN'T HAVE A BREAKDOWN IN TOMORROWLAND
fwee_prower 15th-Nov-2012 08:07 pm (UTC)
well now you need to elaborate
twoyearsaway 15th-Nov-2012 12:22 am (UTC)
i met my boyfriend online. we've been together 3+ years.....but we skyped almost every day before meeting. I can't believe people don't do that first.
xylocarp 15th-Nov-2012 12:27 am (UTC)
Honestly. Especially when they sound like a 14 year old boy (in the first episode of Catfish).
lovekrista 16th-Nov-2012 08:22 am (UTC)
how was the difference between skyping everyday and actually meeting? because i'm at the skyping everyday point with a guy but i'm afraid it won't work irl. :/
twoyearsaway 17th-Nov-2012 03:44 am (UTC)
there really wasn't any difference tbh. there was no awkwardness or anything. i actually flew across the country to meet him (crazy, i know) and everything worked out great. i had met one of his friends before hand when he was visiting family near where i lived so i think that helped too.
Page 6 of 9
<<[1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] >>
This page was loaded Jun 18th 2013, 5:52 am GMT.