ONTD

Exactly. People think that tiny = anorectic. She's clearly well defined because of training and has low body fat. But try to explain that to the majority of ONTD's members who'd rather sit on their ass sipping on a coke while judging others.

Short amount? She's been working out for a long time now. You wanna talk about alarming, talk about Demi Lovato's fluctuating weight. As far as we can see (in results) Miley has been very consistent with her diet and exercise.

She has been working out and getting thinner for months now, that's not such a "short amount of time." It's not like she dropped thirty pounds in thirty days. She also works for her body and it's a result of her doing pilates and running every day. It's one thing if she was dropping weight from starving herself, but her body takes effort and it's obviously something she dedicates time to, especially being as she hasn't really been working the past couple of months (with the exception of recently, when she started recording)

Edit: I also think it's alarming to accuse someone you don't know of being anorexic. Last I checked, you don't live with her, hang out with her, or have access to the food she is eating or isn't eating. Giving up gluten =/= giving up food

Edited at 2012-08-09 10:35 pm (UTC)

If you don't know what I meant with "Anorectic"(I accidentally mixed it with the Swedish word for it, which is where I'm from), then I can absolutely see how you have the opinion that you do. I won't divulge any further into that, since personal attacks are distasteful imo, and also not allowed on ONTD. But I do apologize that you found it hard to apprehend what I meant.

Your facts are completely incorrect, as is unfortunately also your theory. She's done Pilates for a long time. She's also clearly doing other workout sessions. She doesn't look starved in any way.

You can really lose inches from Pilates, though. That's why I love it so much.

ty bb, u are on point

I hope you realize that starving yourself is not the ONLY way people with eating disorders lose weight. Excessive exercise is also extremely common in anorexic people. Of course her body is the result of EFFORT, she's trying to lose weight.

you make it sound as if it's one or the other.

Exactly! Unfortunately it's a loosing battle to try and explain this to they cray-cray's here at ONTD.

lol, this comment plus that icon.

I can completely understand your argument(didn't know she previously said she had issues with food). That's the huge difference though between being unjustly judgmental and actually basing an opinion on actual fact. I have no problem with people having different opinions than me. But it's way too easy to be all "OMG, SHE MUST BE ANOREXIC!!!11!" imo. So I have a hard time accepting people who can't accept that some people are tiny but still healthy. In my opinion, Miley still look healthy at this moment.